17 June 2026
Message from the Market: What the April 2026 PII Market Means for Law Firms
After several consecutive years of a short-lived hard market, the solicitors’ professional indemnity insurance (PII) market is decisively back in favour of buyers. Increased insurer capacity, renewed appetite for growth among established markets, and the arrival of new entrants have combined to create genuine competition.
For well-run firms, this translates into greater negotiating leverage, not just on premiums but also on insurer choice, financial rating strength, policy terms, and the option of long-term policies. This is a window of opportunity that should be approached strategically and with clarity.
However, the market is less soft for firms with a certain profile. Underwriters continue to differentiate carefully between risks. Firms with a high proportion of property work, exposure to mis‑selling or high‑volume litigation, weak governance controls, succession planning concerns, or adverse claims experience will still encounter underwriting discipline, even in a competitive environment.
Conveyancing: Still the Critical Focus
Conveyancing remains the most closely scrutinised discipline within the PII market and continues to attract some of the highest underlying rates. Property claims, both residential and commercial, account for a significant proportion of notifications and a disproportionate share of claim costs, with residential transactions frequently involving allegations of fraud.
Insurer appetite varies widely where property work forms a significant part of the practice. Firms that can clearly demonstrate disciplined processes, effective supervision, consistent file review, and robust anti‑fraud controls are being rewarded through lower pricing and broader insurer choice.
By contrast, firms unable to articulate how risk is managed across volume property work often find the benefits of a soft market more limited.
Looking Beyond Premium Reduction
A buyer‑friendly market should not be viewed solely as a cost‑saving exercise. For many firms, this is an ideal time to review the overall structure and quality of their insurance arrangements.
This may include:
· Reviewing and potentially increasing limits of indemnity
· Upgrading insurer financial strength
· Addressing adverse terms imposed during the hard market
· Reviewing wider protection, such as Cyber and Management Liability insurance
Premium savings can also be redeployed into areas that strengthen the firm’s risk profile and long‑term sustainability, including investment in compliance support, technology, AI solutions, and staff recruitment or retention.
Personal Guarantees and Partner Risk
Particular attention should be paid to the continued presence of personal guarantees within PII documentation, especially for small and mid-sized firms. These provisions are often buried within supplementary paperwork and became common during the hard market.
In the current environment, many of these guarantees are negotiable and in some cases removable. Firms should ensure their broker actively identifies and challenges any such obligations. Renewing a PII policy should not expose partners or directors to unnecessary personal financial risk.
Presentation Still Drives Outcomes
Despite increased competition, underwriters continue to favour firms that present professionally. Clear data, well-prepared submissions, up-to-date claims summaries, and evidence of investment in infrastructure and controls materially influence insurers' appetite.
Where claims have occurred, a concise explanation of the circumstances, supported by demonstrable remedial action, is often sufficient to restore underwriter confidence. Firms that engage openly and commercially with their risk profile consistently achieve better outcomes.
Early Renewals: Convenience Versus Value
Insurers are increasingly keen to secure early renewals in a softening market, often by simplifying the process and requiring minimal information. While this can be attractive from a time‑management perspective, it warrants caution.
Early renewal offers do not always reflect the full extent of market‑wide rate reductions available later in the renewal cycle. Firms that prioritise convenience over engagement may be leaving meaningful savings and structural improvements unrealised.
Choosing the Right Access to Market
Market access matters. Firms insured with A-rated paper may find opportunities to upgrade to stronger financial security in the current climate. Brokers with access to exclusive A+ rated facilities can materially improve both the quality and breadth of insurer options.
It is also important to understand how insurance is placed. Direct access to insurers typically offers greater transparency and flexibility than arrangements relying on delegated authority through Managing General Agents (MGAs). While MGAs can play an important role, their higher cost bases can become more apparent when the market inevitably hardens again.
Policy Coverage: Minimum Versus Optimal
All solicitors’ PII policies must meet the Minimum Terms and Conditions, but many insurers enhance their wordings in different ways. In a competitive market, firms should ensure their policy includes meaningful additional protections, such as:
- Court attendance costs
- Loss of documents cover
- Defence costs for disciplinary proceedings
These enhancements are often available at little or no additional cost but only if actively negotiated.
Final Thought
Soft markets do not last. Firms that benefit most from the current environment are those that treat professional indemnity insurance as a strategic risk‑management tool rather than an annual procurement exercise. The current market represents an opportunity to improve quality, reduce legacy exposures imposed during the hard market, and position the firm strongly for the hard market next cycle.
Let's talk



The Walbrook Building 25 Walbrook London, EC4N 8AW
Privacy Policy - Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information (U.S. Residents Only)
Arthur J. Gallagher (UK) Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered Office: The Walbrook Building, 25 Walbrook, London EC4N 8AW. Registered in England and Wales. Company Number: 119013.

