07 July 2023
Shaping the Future of Corporate Governance
The Impact of ARGA and Redefinition of PIEs
In a time where corporate scandals and unethical practices have shaken public trust, a transformative shift is taking place in the United Kingdom's corporate governance landscape. The Audit Reporting and Governance Authority (ARGA) has emerged as a beacon of change, aiming to restore faith in the country's Audit and Corporate Governance framework. With its introduction comes a redefinition of Public Interest Entities (PIEs), expanding the scope of accountability. These developments are not only reshaping the insurance industry but are also set to impact individual Directors and Officers (D&Os).
Unravelling the Conflict of Interest
The long-awaited UK government response to the audit reform consultation (which began in 2018 in the wake of several high-profile corporate failures) was published in 2022, and with it comes the creation of a new regulatory body named the Audit Reporting and Governance Authority (ARGA).
ARGA's creation is a direct response to a crucial issue plaguing large audit firms — the inherent conflict of interest when providing both audit and consulting services to the same company. By separating these functions, ARGA seeks to address this conflict head-on and regain public confidence. The impact of this move, however, reaches far beyond the realm of accounting services, extending its influence to the responsibilities of individual D&Os.
Expanding the Definition of PIEs
Under the new definition, Public Interest Entities now include companies with annual revenue exceeding GBP 750 million and over 750 employees. This expansion encompasses a substantial number of businesses in today's modern age. Such entities are now subject to various requirements, including the provision of a Resilience Statement, Audit and Assurance Policy, and a Directors' statement on fraud prevention. Moreover, measures are in place to ensure the legality of dividend distribution and reserves. Crucially, ARGA's reach extends to all directors, be they executive or non-executive, emphasising their statutory duties concerning audit and corporate reporting.
Navigating the Regulatory Landscape
While these reforms hold promise for restoring trust, they also present significant challenges for PIEs. The increased regulatory landscape demands a heightened level of internal audit, legal, and compliance functions. ARGA wields substantial investigative powers, empowering them to impose civil sanctions on PIE directors for breaches of duties, enforce the appointment of challenger audit firms, and monitor the obligations of FTSE 350 audit committees. The question of compliance is now at the forefront of corporate strategies, urging businesses to adapt swiftly.
The Rebirth of Governance in the ESG Equation
These developments have rekindled the focus on the "G" in Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) risk factors for D&O insurers. As environmental and social aspects have recently taken centre stage, the introduction of ARGA and its emphasis on corporate governance marks a renewed commitment to accountability. Transparency is the cornerstone of this new era, fostering public trust and shaping the future landscape of D&O insurance and corporate governance in the United Kingdom and the United States.
In a world where corporate misbehaviour has become all too common, the introduction of ARGA and the redefinition of PIEs signify a ground-breaking shift towards restoring trust and transparency in the UK's corporate governance framework.
To Conclude
ARGA's efforts to separate audit and non-audit functions within large audit firms address the long-standing conflict of interest, while also placing increased accountability on individual D&Os. The expanded definition of PIEs brings numerous requirements and challenges for companies, necessitating a strategic approach to compliance and corporate practices. These regulatory changes not only shape the future of D&O insurance but also re-establish the importance of governance in the broader ESG equation. By prioritising corporate transparency and accountability, the United Kingdom is leading the charge in rebuilding public trust and setting a new standard for corporate practices worldwide.
The Walbrook Building 25 Walbrook London, EC4N 8AW
Let's talk
Arthur J. Gallagher (UK) Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Registered Office: The Walbrook Building, 25 Walbrook, London EC4N 8AW. Registered in England and Wales. Company Number: 119013.